Showing posts with label Invalid argument. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Invalid argument. Show all posts

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Invalid argument: You're not a woman

I love how often, when people say this, they say it as if they are bringing new information to the table. As if they have discovered something that no one else is aware of. As if they have just seen through my clever disguise, and point their accusatory index finger against and say "AHA! You're not a REAL woman"

Well I have never claimed to be a woman, and I've never really felt a need to claim to be a woman, because if something is true when a woman says it, it is true when a man says it. Truth is not related to the gender of the one who speaks it.

I'll some times feel emboldened to speak on moral issues that concern women. Such as for example abortion. If abortion is wrong, it doesn't become right because I'm a man and can't become pregnant. So it seems strange to bring that up in an abortion debate. It would be similar to saying that black people are disqualified from saying slavery is wrong because they didn't qualify to own slaves.




Friday, March 4, 2011

Invalid argument: I'm older than you

So here's my problem. At 27 years old I'm still a whipper snapper, and frequently I find myself in a debate with someone older than myself. If you have ever been in that situation I'm sure you are familiar with the ultimate debate-killer: "I'm older than you, so I know better."

Well alright, if you want to play that game, then all I need to do to get the upper hand again is find someone who takes my side who is even older than you. I'll say "this guy is a fossil, and he agrees with me. Now what do you have to say?"

But that's not how truth works. If it was we should all get on the phone and ask this lady to resolve all the questions for us.


Besse Cooper, at 114 years is the oldest person alive today. So if you can get this lady on your side, you can win every debate you'll ever find yourself in.

While it's true that some wisdom comes with age, and generally older people have had more experiences to draw wisdom from, there is not an absolute link between age and being right. If two people disagree on something it is not always the oldest one that is right

So let's talk about actual arguments, and not about seniority.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...